Sylvia Plath |
I read through the poem on my own before we discussed it as a class.
You do not do, you do not do
Any
more, black shoe
In
which I have lived like a foot
For
thirty years, poor and white,
Barely
daring to breathe or Achoo.
At
that first reading I saw a poem about a father's shoe. It was the sad
poem of a girl who's father died and a whole lot of symbolism
that went right over my head.
But
then we talked about it in class and my eyes were opened to the
beauty of meaning hidden inside words. Suddenly the shoe in that
first stanza was not just a shoe, but a weapon a father used
to beat his daughter. It became the place that a sad little girl hid
from her father and felt as cared for as a foot.
The
repetition in the first line wasn't just to take up space but
a type of rhythm that made the poem sound sing-song-y like a
little girl who still calls her father "Daddy". In fact,
the first stanza often gets stuck in my head like a nursery rhyme.
The
more I understood, the more the imagery seeped into my mind.
Bit
my pretty red heart in two.
And
they stuck me together with glue.
The
voices just can't worm through.
There's
a stake in your fat black heart
And
how could I ignore the Rhyme Scheme that really
makes the whole poem have that nursery rhyme feeling? The word 'you'
and words that rhyme with 'you' are present at the end of many of the
lines.
The
whole poem is so depressingly beautiful. I find it odd that this is a
poem that I connect with considering I've never had any experience in
abuse and I had a very attentive father. But every time I read this
poem, I am transported back to that desk in that classroom in Georgia
and I'm reading it again for the first time and realizing that words
are not just words. I'm finding a love in a type of writing that I
can never hope to truly understand but that I will continue to read
to feel the way it makes me feel.
There is a lot of diction in her poem I'm unfamiliar with. Anyone know what a Frisco seal is?
ReplyDeleteI also feel like she indulges in hyperbole ... "a Jew to Dachau"? Really ...?
I went and read the whole poem, using Charly's link (Thank you, Charly). The persona really does cry out in pain. Reading it, I was filled with horror at the thought of what he must have done to her to cause her to choose such biting metaphors and violent diction.
ReplyDeleteI love the image of "stake in your fat black heart." You really get her anger
ReplyDeleteA great personal literary narrative, and some good comments and additions by Charly and Leah!
ReplyDeleteI like that "There's a stake in your fat black heart" doesn't rhyme. I feel like it makes it more macabre.
ReplyDelete